Changeset: 126572662
removed unconfirmed information
Closed by Anti1982
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18543 uk) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from michael_ua
Чому ви видалили всі назви російською мовою?
-
Comment from woodpeck
Please explain what you mean by "remove unvconfirmed information". More precisely, you have chosen not to remove the German name of https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1084442724 - does the street have a German street sign and therefore you treated this name as "confirmed" while the Russian name was "unconfirmed"? Or are you simply blanket-deleting name:ru tags without regard to anything else? In that case, has this automated edit been discussed in the Ukrainian community?
-
Comment from woodpeck
What kind of "confirmation" is necessary and whom would this confirmation have to be sent to? Will you proceed to delete other things because you have not received "confirmation"?
-
Comment from iWowik
Anti1982 is one account of
https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/Poliakoff%20Mykhailo
So it is not wonder he did not remove German name which is mapped by himself -
Comment from Poliakoff Mykhailo
in Western Ukraine, Russian is not a local language at all. Street names do not have official names in Russian, nor do they have colloquial names in Russian.
All signs on the houses are written in Ukrainian, Hungarian or RomanianEverything written in name:ru streets is a fantasy of online translators.
I warned the Ukrainian community about the intention to delete name:ru in western Ukraine
-
Comment from Poliakoff Mykhailo
I plan to remove name:ru from the streets in my town of Malyn, Zhytomyr oblast
Delete because I went around the whole town and did not find a single sign on the house in Russian. All local indigenous residents of the city speak Ukrainian. It was not possible to find confirmation of Russian street names. Therefore, I also believe that name:ru in the town of Malyn is a fantasy of online translators
-
Comment from muchichka_s
Please note that most of these translations were added by one user without any discussion of this import
He even had a block due to this import. And even after that, he did not try to reconcile these periodic imports
https://www.openstreetmap.org/user_blocks/6174Meanwhile, the russian occupiers are burning Ukrainian books in the occupied territories:
https://twitter.com/MelSimmonsFCDO/status/1527951794734784512So I think this removal should be considered a return to the Status Quo
- Лісова вулиця (516869489), v9
- Квітнева вулиця (516869490), v6
- Ольги Кобилянської вулиця (285472183), v6
- Середня вулиця (285472184), v6
- Водна вулиця (285472185), v6
- Вузька вулиця (285472186), v7
- Руська вулиця (285472189), v5
- Олекси Довбуша вулиця (285472190), v6
- Стрипна вулиця (285472191), v12
- Середня вулиця (285472193), v7
- Вузька вулиця (285472194), v6
- Космонавтів вулиця (285472196), v6
- Лесі Українки Бічна вулиця (285472197), v9
- Максима Рильського вулиця (285472199), v5
- Максима Рильського вулиця (285472203), v4
- Циганська вулиця (187637147), v13
- Вагилевича вулиця (187637148), v14
- За Рудкою провулок (187637149), v12
- Академіка Горбачевського вулиця (187637150), v11
- Котляревського вулиця (187637153), v24
Nodes (5)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |