Changeset: 125199848
Fix minor errors
Closed by user_5589
Tags
changesets_count | 35122 |
---|---|
created_by | iD 2.21.1 |
host | https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit |
imagery_used | BDOrtho IGN |
locale | en-GB |
resolved:close_nodes:vertices | 1 |
resolved:outdated_tags:deprecated_tags | 14 |
resolved:outdated_tags:incomplete_tags | 5 |
resolved:outdated_tags:noncanonical_brand | 495 |
warnings:mismatched_geometry:point_as_vertex | 1 |
Discussion
-
Comment from SHARCRASH
Hi!
For https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/610231135 landuse=basin is not an error. There are people who find this tag to be more accurate than natural=water + water=basin because clearly the feature is a land that has been shaped to contain water, i's not really a natural feature: it's rectangular, there is a weir/dam to hold water. All this as the definition states.The landuse=basin exists since 2009 and has more than 200k elements whereas the new combo tag exists only since 2020 and 100k elements. Cleary this is already a duplicated tag.
You've been doing this on several of your changesets and in areas very far appart. Another example here where you've chnaged 4 of them https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/125908527 So this can be considered like war tagging! By the way, the fact that you do not describe exactly what you do in your changeset is shady. So I ask you politely to stop imposing your "tag preferences" and respect tags that have been voted and established for more than a decade otherwise I'll report you.
-
Comment from SHARCRASH
By the way about the "natural=" key,
I'm in discussion in the Wiki page to denounce the "sudden" change of the definition in 2020. Previously the definition never stated that the natural key can integrate artificial features. Discussion here: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Key:natural#Natural_??? -
Comment from user_5589
Take it up with the maintainers of iD. Their validator marks it as invalid tagging, and it seems reasonable to do so. I have my own fundamental disagreements with maintainers of validators etc over tagging concerning tagging of lanes and the way Osmose handles things so I can understand where such feelings come from.
To quote from the information in this changeset:
resolved:close_nodes:vertices 1
resolved:outdated_tags:deprecated_tags 14
resolved:outdated_tags:incomplete_tags 5
resolved:outdated_tags:noncanonical_brand 495
warnings:mismatched_geometry:point_as_vertex 1Those are minor errors and I resolved them. Hence fixing minor errors. Hence the changeset comment.
-
Comment from SHARCRASH
Thank you very much for the information! I didn't know and understand now. I will contact them.
My feelings are motivated by logic and respecting what has been accepeted by community. The natural key has never included artificial features. Also I'm fed up of duplicated tag schemes for the same feature, it's becoming more common every once in a while.
For the changeset description, OK i see but it is still a very general description like some others do in OSM. So it's not really relevant and helping other contributors understand what changes you did, therefore not really transparent. I think you can easily make an effort for the descriptions.
Thanks again on the enlightenment for iD! Have a great continuation!
- ligne 63 kV Landres - Tucquegneux (184499726), v8
- Liaison 63 kV n°1 Fontoy - Landres (207529024), v10
- 207579146, v6
- 238074475, v4
- 343078904, v10
- 343661087, v5
- 354894206, v4
- 354895641, v4
- 354896351, v7
- 354896582, v6
- 354899419, v6
- 354900077, v6
- 354900968, v8
- 354901960, v8
- 354907583, v6
- 354910232, v4
- 364666937, v4
- 368360468, v4
- 368360469, v4
- 368440294, v4
Relations (6)
- Ligne de Longuyon à Onville et Pagny-sur-Moselle (1878429), v32
- Ligne de Valleroy-Moineville à Villerupt-Micheville (6363309), v18
- Voie 1 de la ligne de Longuyon à Onville et Pagny-sur-Moselle (6363543), v11
- Voie unique de la ligne de Baroncourt à Audun-le-Roman (section Bouligny-Audun-le-Roman) (7366123), v3
- Ligne de Baroncourt à Audun-le-Roman (7366126), v2
- Centre Hospitalier de Briey (12647444), v2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |