Changeset: 116776328
Add road smoothness
Closed by MapMan420
Tags
StreetComplete:quest_type | AddRoadSmoothness |
---|---|
created_by | StreetComplete 39.1 |
locale | en-US |
source | survey |
Discussion
-
Comment from smootheFiets
Hoi MapMan420,
Wat leuk dat je smoothness toevoegt (naast andere leuke dingen), goed bezig! Ik zie echter dat je een paar keer smoothness=excellent toepast bij surface=paving_stones. Dat is niet per se onmogelijk, maar toch heel ongebruikelijk. Zie ook https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:smoothness/Gallery
Zeker dat je op deze klinkers lekker kunt skeeleren? Op Google Street View (geen toegestane bron voor OSM-edits natuurlijk) oogt de Gedempte Vaart hooguit smoothness=good (liever niet doen op skeelers, op de racefiets OK). De meeste klinkerwegen in onze streek hebben eerder smoothness=intermediate (wel te doen op de racefiets als er geen strakkere plan B is, prima op 37mm-banden).Zou je nog eens willen kijken? Ik ken Surhuisterveen niet goed genoeg om het meteen zelf aan te passen. Ben er wel een paar keer langs gefietst (vooral voor de Pieter Weening Classic), dus ik weet zo'n beetje waarover ik praat.
Grout'n uut het Westerketier,
smootheFiets -
Comment from smootheFiets
I just noticed locale=en-US in your edit summary... So in case your Dutch is not so hot, let me repeat the above in English (it's easier on me than Dutch, anyway):
I'm very happy to see you adding smoothness tags to a bunch of ways - thumbs up! That's probably my biggest mapping hobby, and I'm glad to see it picked up by others.
However, smoothness=excellent in combination with surface=paving_stones strikes me as unusual / incredible. You've assigned that combo to, e.g., Gedempte Vaart https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/182555054
I kinda know the area, see e.g. https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/90465765. I would've noticed paving stones _that_ good.excellent means: nice on roller blades. That's reserved for the finest asphalt / concrete. It's not unheard of on paving stones, but excessively rare.
Even 'good' paving stones are moderately rare in our area, where good means: nice on a road bike, OK on roller blades.
Typically, they're intermediate: no-go on roller blades, OK on the road bike, but you'd happily trade them for an alternative smoothness=good route, even at the expense of a moderate detour.This gallery https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:smoothness/Gallery is useful for reference (it's also linked from https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:smoothness )
Would you care to take a second look and to adjust smoothness as needed? I'd be very grateful. Also, I'd be happy to hear any comments you may have.
Greetings from (just) across the Groningen/Fryslân divide ;)
smootheFiets
Ways (18)
- 517904141, v3
- Badlaan (6465120), v10
- 1025927535, v3
- Badlaan (6465007), v14
- Badlaan (843683015), v9
- Zandpol (6465058), v11
- 517904139, v3
- 517904140, v3
- Zandpol (6465328), v14
- Gedempte Vaart (695570137), v8
- Vermaning (1025610205), v2
- Baggelkamp (6465029), v10
- Badlaan (6465094), v10
- Eisingarak (6465325), v11
- 1021771391, v3
- Bloemkamp (6465127), v11
- Gedempte Vaart (6465023), v17
- 517904143, v5
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |