Changeset: 114580539
adjusted Russian territorial sea in Caspian Sea to 12nm
Closed by hanzlan
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18303 de) |
---|---|
source | marineregions.org |
Discussion
-
Comment from chnav
Hi, I have few complains to your edit.
1. You have mapped from resource with unknown and not confirmed accuracy. MarineRegions might be good for MarineTraffic (plus-minus fer miles) but definetely is not that accurate in less mapped regions. Can you confirm what sources are used by MarineRegions to map the border of Russia in Caspian Sea ? Was it old Soviet maps or simple shoreliine offset ?
2. 12 nm are 22.224 km and not 25 km
3. Caspian Sea is special region where Convention of 5 countries is implemented. It states 15 nm from baseline and not 12 nm. I do not think MarineRegions used baseline for this purpose but simple shoreline which changes every year d/t very shallow water. Mean sea level averaged for couple of years ip not that simple to define.
4. Any edits of international boundaries must be discussed with local community, which has more local knowledge.You edit is subject to revert. Please be more accurate in mapping.
-
Comment from chnav
Changeset is fully reverted.
-
Comment from chnav
Any import MUST be discussed prior edit.
Ways (1-20 of 21)
- 1
- 2
- 1009288842, v1
- 1009288843, v1
- 1009288844, v1
- Border Kazakhstan - Russia (1009288845), v1
- 1009288846, v1
- 137586627, v4
- Border Kazakhstan - Russia (289885486), v2
- 367840790, v2
- 579676643, v3
96122580, v596122581, v696122583, v4137991421, v4137991476, v5137991496, v4137991532, v4137991540, v12137991555, v4367840785, v2394608067, v2
Relations (18)
- Россия (60189), v1802
- Калмыкия (108083), v130
- Дагестан (109876), v128
- Астраханская область (112819), v81
- Қазақстан (214665), v478
- Курмангазинский район (214670), v27
- Атырауская область (214834), v59
- Северо-Кавказский федеральный округ (389344), v228
- Лаганский район (938734), v17
- Южный федеральный округ (1059500), v390
- Российско-казахстанская граница (2887759), v186
- Северо-Кавказский экономический район (3560388), v244
- Поволжский экономический район (3560889), v255
- Московское время (3563652), v780
- Южный военный округ (3564042), v295
- Самарское время (4297465), v140
- Северное сельское поселение (5467207), v4
- 10714708, v2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |