Changeset: 114545684
Convert more bodies of seawater off Saint Lawrence River estuary to relations, following "one point, one name" rule; "ocean"="yes" tag added to give other mappers opportunity to filter out this data, as per discussion on talk-ca mailing list
Closed by DENelson83
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18303 en) |
---|---|
source | Existing OSM data; CanVec |
Discussion
-
Comment from DENelson83
In case you are wondering why it looks like part of the St. Lawrence Estuary has "dried up", it is because the coastline has been extended in this area, and it will take a bit of time for the coastline rendering routine in the OSM-Carto tiles to catch up to this.
-
Comment from PierZen
Vous avez modifié le polygone de l'Estuaire moyen en le faisant teminer avant Rivière-du-Loup. Tel que documenté dans wikipedia, cet estuaire se prolonge jusqu'à Point-des-Monts à la jonction avec l'Estuaire maritime.
Pourriez-vous svp réparer?
-
Comment from DENelson83
Sorry, but that would cut the area with that name into two parts. The Chenal du Nord and Chenal du Sud are in the way. I use a guideline called "one point, one name" when naming bodies of seawater, and I have an additional guideline that says that a body of seawater with a single name cannot be cut into two disjoint areas.
-
Comment from PierZen
Je ne vois rien dans la discussion sur Talk-ca qui vous permettait de décider de réviser des objets tels que les estuaires et ajouter ce que vous appellez one point - one name. Svp, remettre comme avant, sinon discutez de vos modifications sur talk-ca
-
Comment from DENelson83
You are putting me in an uncomfortable situation. You are now the second person to have challenged my personal "one point, one name" guideline.
-
Comment from DENelson83
I will have to remove "Chenal du Nord" and "Chenal du Sud" in order to re-extend the Middle St. Lawrence Estuary area.
50736285, v450736287, v450736290, v350736291, v350736292, v350736293, v350736297, v350736298, v350736299, v350736302, v350751581, v1550751628, v350751631, v350751708, v750751711, v752062669, v352062670, v452062671, v652062684, v352062686, v3
- Anse à Gilles (13509031), v1
- Chenal de Beaujeu (13509032), v1
- Anse à la Béguine (13509033), v1
- Anse à Félix (13509034), v1
- Anse à Anty (13509035), v1
- Anse du Nord-Est (13509036), v1
- Anse à Biquette (13509037), v1
- Anse aux Grêlons (13509038), v1
- Anse à Beaufils (13509039), v1
- Anse à la Chaux (13509040), v1
- Chenal de Saint-Thomas (13509041), v1
- Le Bassin (13509042), v1
- Anse du Cap (13509043), v1
- 13509044, v1
- 13509045, v1
- Passage de la Quarantaine (13509046), v1
- Passe Patience (13509047), v1
- Île d'Orléans (13509048), v1
- Île au Ruau (13509049), v1
- Île aux Grues (13509050), v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |