Changeset: 113460988
#fastag Obertura Túnel Glòries sentit Besòs (Catalunya)
Closed by yopaseopor
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (17702 en) |
---|---|
hashtags | #fastag |
source | PNOA |
Discussion
-
Comment from ivanbranco
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/263327088
Why you added 2021-11-05 to every tag? From the wiki: "Add the suffix specifying a year or date range to the main key or other relevant tags. The suffix is not needed for attributes which did not change over time." This highway has this tagged name since 7 years so I don't think this is the case.
Also "name:2021-11-05=*" means that that value is valid ONLY in that date. It should be "name:-2021-11-05=*" if it ended on that date or "name:2021-11-05-=*" if it started since that date.
-
Comment from yopaseopor
Hola! Salutacions des de Barcelona ciutat. Greetings from Barcelona. As you know this way has changed a lot during last week. For the first time, general traffic is avoid of the surface. So this way is no more the main road of "Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes" but unforgettable for someone who lives in this city. For this reason I have added the date to all the keys (this way should not be showed in Carto more but also inside is good to remain inside OSM). And yes, a specific date, because I cannot afford all the past from this way (in name and other conditions) and can only afford the last day of that) .Putting -xxxx would be negative numbers in normal mathematics (and also on OSM database) so it is not a good solution. And put a hyphen empty has nosense.
Also there is some software who starts to show these keys, used in all around the world as you can see also in taginfo. -
Comment from ivanbranco
"Putting -xxxx would be negative numbers in normal mathematics (and also on OSM database) so it is not a good solution. And put a hyphen empty has nosense."
Ehm, that's literally what the Wiki says to do: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Date_namespace
as you can see it's used: https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/search?q=name%3A-
In OSM rules, as the Wiki says:
-"name:2021-11-05=Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes" means that the name was Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes only in that specific day.
-"name:-2021-11-05=Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes" means that the name was that one in a "open-ended interval until end of the specified date". -
Comment from yopaseopor
I will not discuss about what's on the wiki. As you can see in taginfo both solutions are used. I can assure and I think is better for being adjusted to truth this day. When you put one day you don't mean yesterday it was not this name also. You can "certificate" a specific day. So this is the option I have chosen.
Ways (15)
- Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes (1000038391), v1
- 1000038392, v1
- Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes (1000038393), v1
- Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes (22725250), v41
- 22725435, v26
- 263327088, v10
- 263421796, v15
- Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes (288840915), v13
- Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes (321003859), v11
- Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes (330630823), v5
- 363815622, v4
- Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes (526135941), v4
- Gran Via de les Corts Catalanes (545724435), v7
- 771104305, v2
- 942889964, v3
Relations (1-20 of 28)
- 1
- 2
- 7: Zona Universitària => Fòrum (3200493), v138
- N81 Barcelona - Vilassar de Dalt (3918298), v51
- e11.1: Barcelona => Mataró Centre (4064675), v75
- e11.2: Barcelona => Mataró Nord (4100154), v79
- H12: Gornal => Besòs-Verneda (4799268), v48
- C6 Barcelona - Villasar de Mar-- Cabrils (5731871), v29
- N2 L'Hospitalet de L. => Pl. Catalunya => Badalona (7522242), v159
- N7 Pedralbes => Pl. Catalunya => Fòrum (7589319), v69
- e19: Barcelona => Alella (8256963), v28
- Flixbus N740: Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos => Venedig, Tronchetto (9849734), v139
- Flixbus N728: Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos => München, ZOB (9850347), v129
- Flixbus 721: Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos => Bordeaux, Parking Descas (9850914), v64
- Flixbus 728: Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos => Genua, Fanti d'Italia/Principe (9851018), v108
- Flixbus 1721: Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos => Toulouse, Gare Routière (9851088), v45
- Flixbus N758: Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos => Florenz, Villa Costanza (9884287), v108
- Flixbus N708: Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos => Niza, Aeropuerto Terminal 2 (9921553), v103
- Flixbus N710: Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos => Essen, Hbf. (9924323), v188
- Flixbus 788: Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos => Lyon, Perrache (9924482), v58
- Flixbus N788: Barcelona, terminal de l'aeroport 2 => Genève, gare routière internationale (9924675), v85
- Flixbus N1720: Barcelona Nord, Estació d'autobusos => Mainz, Hbf. (9929281), v182
Nodes (5)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |