Changeset: 112428221
Poste suisse
Closed by BBMaper
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18193 fr) |
---|---|
source | observation |
Discussion
-
Comment from Picea
Hello BBMaper,
you deleted many post-office-nodes (including their version-history) and created new ones almost in the same places. Why did you choose to do so, instead of simply editing the existing nodes?
Furthermore, in some cases information, that was in the "old" nodes, was omitted. For example, by the change from node 471583274 (deleted) to node 9167919053 (created), the tags "wheelchair=yes" and "post_office:type=post_partner" are no longer there. Was this on purpose? If yes: why?
Best regards
Picea -
Comment from SimonPoole
Hi BBMaper
We are discussing what to do with your problematic changesets on the Swiss mailing list, here http://lists.openstreetmap.ch/pipermail/talk-ch/2021-November/011335.htmlWithout further comment from your side we are going to ask the DWG to revert all the relevant changes, so it would be a good idea to explain what you were doing.
-
Comment from BBMaper
Hello, My modification was done to increase the quality of OSM which is a great project I want to help.
Effectively with the help of existing osm and the swiss post website (I always put the link to the post page, I corrected all the post offices in CH.
Many of them where missing and many where closed (replaced by post office in shop)
I tried to put always the official name.
Sorry for not answering before, but I did not noticed messages before his morning. -
Comment from SimonPoole
Hi, naturally improving the data is welcome, the problem here is that you deleted wholesale the original elements and lost both the history and details that had been previously added. The other issue is that before using a 3rd party data source we need to determine is we are allowed to do so, which in this case didn't happen. But as said above discussing how to proceed would be better suited to the Swiss mailing list.
Ways (3)
- Volg (9167919035), v1
- Volg (9167919036), v1
- Volg (9167919037), v1
- Post 4402 Frenkendorf (9167919038), v1
- Post 4334 Sisseln AG (9167919039), v1
- Post 4410 Liestal (9167919040), v1
- Post 5325 Leibstadt (9167919041), v1
- Post 5312 Döttingen-Klingnau (9167919042), v1
- Post 4414 Füllinsdorf (9167919043), v1
- Post 8195 Wasterkingen (9167919044), v1
- Post 8197 Rafz (9167919045), v1
- Post 4323 Wallbach (9167919046), v1
- Post 8194 Hüntwangen (9167919047), v1
- Post 5080 Laufenburg (9167919048), v1
- Post 4133 Pratteln 1 (9167919049), v1
- Post 5330 Bad Zurzach (9167919050), v1
- Post 5316 Leuggern (9167919051), v1
- Post 8196 Wil ZH (9167919052), v1
- Post 4303 Kaiseraugst Liebrüti (9167919053), v1
- Post 5274 Mettau (9167919054), v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |