Changeset: 111030390
HK bike network prelim fix NT YL section roads
Closed by Kovoschiz
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18193 en) |
---|---|
source | local knowledge; streetlevel imagery; aerial imagery; gps; |
Discussion
-
Comment from emvee
Hi Kovoschiz,
In this changeset you added pieces of cycleway with:
highway=cycleway
bicycle=no
bicycle:conditional=yes @ (dismount)and:
highway=cycleway
bicycle=no
bicycle:lanes:conditional=designated|no|designated @ (dismount)That is quite confusing:
* if is it highway=cycleway, it should not be bicycle=no
* the conditional tags seems to indicate you have to dismount, if so, why not use "bicycle=dismount", or even better, make that piece of road highway=footway
* bicycle:lanes:conditional? Does the cycle track have multiple lines?NB: I found these ways looking at:
Greetings,
Martin.
-
Comment from Kovoschiz
1. This is the strange local situation. A lot of old sections require dismount at crossings on a cycle track, so this is the reality. Alternatively, I can use `=path`.
2. I wanted to keep it as a `=cycleway`, since this is what is is. I read there are controversies with `bicycle=dismount`. I also prefer using `*:conditional=`, for these use values.
3. Yes, the marked "median" for pedestrians can be quite long, so I decided it's more of a lane. -
Comment from emvee
Thanks for the details, understood that you are required to dismount at crossings on a cycle track.
I am not sure where your preferences for using condition @ dismount comes for but I think it is not a good idea because there is a simpler solution (bicycle=dismount). OSM data is also use by routing engine and I am quite sure they do not understand things like "bicycle:conditional=yes @ (dismount)"
- 寶業街 Po Yip Street (981654726), v1
- 寶業街 Po Yip Street (981654727), v1
- 981654728, v1
- 981654729, v1
- 981654730, v1
- 981654731, v1
- 981654732, v1
- 981654733, v1
- 981654734, v1
- 981654735, v1
- 981654736, v1
- 981654737, v1
- 981654738, v1
- 981654739, v1
- 981654740, v1
- 寶業街 Po Yip Street (981654741), v1
- 寶業街 Po Yip Street (981654742), v1
- 981654743, v1
- 981654744, v1
- 981654745, v1
Relations (11)
- 13191660, v1
- 13191661, v1
- 13191662, v1
- 1821671, v2
- 龍運巴士A37線 Long Win Bus A37 (機場 Airport → 朗屏站 Long Ping Station) (6504565), v68
- 港鐵巴士K74綫 MTR Bus K74 (天瑞 Tin Shui ↺ 凹頭 Au Tau) (6563799), v48
- 9134296, v145
- 元朗區地區幹綫 Local Cycle Track of Yuen Long (9883142), v17
- 龍運巴士A37線 Long Win Bus A37 (機場 Airport → 朗屏站 Long Ping Station (經機場博覽館 via AsiaWorld-Expo)) (12102413), v19
- 龍運巴士E36A線 Long Win Bus E36A (元朗 Yuen Long → 逸東 Yat Tung) (12102510), v15
- 龍運巴士E36A線 Long Win Bus E36A (逸東邨 Yat Tung Estate → 元朗 Yuen Long) (12102594), v17
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |