Changeset: 98324226
Updated road information, altered some highway classifications to better reflect those of the Road Authority, fixed highway geometries in Hafnarfjörður
Closed by Tómas Ingi
Tags
changesets_count | 3678 |
---|---|
created_by | iD 2.19.5 |
host | https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit |
imagery_used | Maxar Premium Imagery (Beta);Bing aerial imagery |
locale | is |
resolved:almost_junction:highway-highway | 1 |
Discussion
-
Comment from Burricane
Hello Tómas Ingi!
I noticed that you have made some recent edits to ref networks and road classifications in Reykjavik. I’m curious about some of the changes, because they don’t seem to be supported by the most recent Vegaskrá from 2020: http://www.vegagerdin.is/vefur2.nsf/Files/Vegaskra_2020/$file/Vegaskra_2020.xlsx and http://www.vegagerdin.is/media/vegakerfid/Vidhengi_nr.xlsx. By my understanding, the Viðhengi lists highways that will be managed by local municipalities, but have not been formally returned to them, according to the description here: http://www.vegagerdin.is/vegakerfid/vegaskra/. To me, this disclaimer suggests the `ref` tags should remain in place. Do you have additional knowledge I might not be aware of to make these changes?
Thanks, I am curious to hear your thoughts!
Burricane -
Comment from Tómas Ingi
Hi Burricane,
That's true, I forgot to look at the addendum!
I suppose that it's a matter of judgement whether these roads should be considered a part of the national highway network, since they are de jure managed (or supposed to be managed) by the local municipalities; does the highway number go when it is formally handed over is it no longer relevant already? I'm personally not sure which is better.
-
Comment from Burricane
Hello again Tómas Ingi!
I think it would be best to retain these refs until they are formally returned to the local municipality and removed from the addendum. That's how I interpret the statement on http://www.vegagerdin.is/vegakerfid/vegaskra/. Alternatively, the loc_ref tag may be suitable (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:ref#Key_variations) but I am not confident that is totally appropriate and I think it would be best if there was agreement from the greater Icelandic OSM Community before committing to that scheme. What are your thoughts on this?
Thanks!
Burricane -
Comment from Tómas Ingi
Hi,
That sounds good; we'll add the ref/network tags to those roads which are still formally administered by Vegagerðin.
-
Comment from Burricane
Hi Tómas Ingi,
I went ahead and added the refs back into the map, based on the Vegagerðin spreadsheets and what previously existed in the data. Let me know if you notice any problems with changes and we can come up with a solution. Thank you for the help, it’s much appreciated!
Burricane
- 901393220, v1
- 901393221, v1
- 901393222, v1
- 901393223, v1
- Fornubúðir (901393224), v1
- Vesturgata (901393225), v1
- 901393226, v1
- 901393227, v1
- Hringbraut (901393228), v1
- Hringbraut (901393229), v1
- Suðurbraut (901393230), v1
- Bústaðavegur (4347809), v52
- Bústaðavegur (5068252), v12
- Reykjavíkurvegur (5188124), v39
- Reykjavíkurvegur (5188202), v19
- Arnarnesvegur (12299759), v16
- Strandgata (22552774), v16
- Strandgata (22552794), v19
- Strandgata (22552934), v13
- Strandgata (22553360), v18
Relations (1-20 of 32)
- 1
- 2
- 12247037, v1
- 12247038, v1
- 12247039, v1
- 12247040, v1
- 12247041, v1
- 12247042, v1
- 12247043, v1
- 12247044, v1
- Bessastaðavegur (12247045), v1
- 12247046, v1
- 12247047, v1
- 12247048, v1
- Arnarnesvegur (66591), v67
- Bústaðavegur (66609), v49
- Álftanesvegur (79806), v17
- Suðurbraut (2245383), v13
- Hringbraut (2262821), v15
- Vesturgata (2296975), v13
- Fornubúðir (2341638), v7
- Strætó bs. 1 Vellir-Hlemmur (3962957), v100
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |