Changeset: 76573042
Clean up opening_hours, service_times, collection_times in the US Midwest (North Dakota, South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin, Ohio, Michigan, Missouri); other misc. edits on the same data (incomplete, some errors/warnings unfixed)
Closed by skquinn
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (15492 en) |
---|---|
review_requested | yes |
source | OpenStreetMap Carto (Standard) |
Discussion
-
Comment from user_5359
This change record should be reversed:
*For one, the range of changes is too large,
* parks are set as points, although they already exist as areas,
* churches are created that are definitely not churches (company creates fans) and
* the standards for the spelling of values are not met. -
Comment from skquinn
> *For one, the range of changes is too large,
Yes, larger than normal, but going one state at a time was getting to be tedious and in many cases I was only finding one or two things that needed fixing.
> * parks are set as points, although they already exist as areas,
If this did happen it's because a park node existed with an opening_hours tag and the park area was not. I am in favor of merging the fixed data into the area and deleting the now-duplicate node if that's the case anywhere.
> * churches are created that are definitely not churches (company creates fans) and
Any such fake churches existed before I edited the service_times/opening_hours tag on them (or cleaned up things like invalid characters in description, which were a small number of the overall edits).
> * the standards for the spelling of values are not met.
I fixed as many of these as I could find but I wanted to get the fixes I had up before the data got too stale and I risked having to fix even more conflicts than I did.
-
Comment from SomeoneElse
On the "fake churches" thing - there have been a number of these added by a spammer (a quick search of OSM US' slack finds https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/65926182 , but there are many more).
From the perspective of someone who (with a DWG hat on) sometimes gets asked to tidy up this stuff, "fixing" the opening hours on them is extremely unhelpful because it makes the underlying problem harder to fix - please don't do it.
If you're not looking at the data closely enough to notice that https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/6869591593/history is unlikely to be a place of worship ("all hail the almighty fan"), then this is clearly a mechanical edit and needs to be reverted.
One question remains - how many earlier changesets need to be reverted for the same reason?
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group. -
Comment from skquinn
That was probably one of the few places that threw a warning for unprintable characters or trailing spaces. Those, I will admit, I apparently didn't look as closely at as I should have (but I have since fixed it).
-
Comment from user_5359
Hello, Andy! Thanks for the support. If you don't mind, I would take care of the churches topic in the change sentences. Unfortunately there is not only the topic spammers, but also duplicates and spelling mistakes.
-
Comment from SomeoneElse
@user_5359 No problem - let us know if you want us to do anything.
-
Comment from HubMiner
> * parks are set as points, although they already exist as areas,
Question to all: is there a Quality Checker that highlights this condition?
-
Comment from user_5359
Not used in this case.
But have a look on https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Overpass_API/Overpass_API_by_Example#Count_Pharmacies_per_County_.28updated_0.7.54.29
It should be possible to search all areas with the tag leisure=park and then count the number of nodes with the tag leisure=park within the area.
- Prestige Glass Co., Inc. (147835055), v5
- Buffalo Wild Wings (192761193), v4
- 7-Eleven (210325292), v5
- Jara's Auto Rebuilders (211395763), v3
- Mariscos Almada (211395778), v3
- Goebbert's Farm & Garden Center of South Barrington (338426841), v4
- Community Banks of Shelby County (444342093), v2
- Tanglez Hair and Tanning Salon (444342311), v2
- Glockenspiel (456282682), v4
- Sangamon River Forest Preserve (564449101), v3
- St Louis Coffee World (627801919), v2
- Latino Market (698747754), v2
- Instants (710765939), v2
- Urbieta Construction, Inc. (725991752), v5
- Rochester Area Foundation (140643128), v5
- Pizza Hut (345801233), v3
- Burger King (548040547), v3
- McDonald's (550207535), v4
- Magic Dragon Golf & Games (618191777), v2
- Family & Cosmetic Dentistry: Grindling & Tobola (733692219), v2
Relations (2)
- Tower Post Office (349590582), v4
- New Straitsville Post Office (357529674), v4
- Rainbow Garden (2805245215), v2
- Kampsville Post Office (3430870647), v2
- Northeast Technical Services, Inc. (5756749023), v2
- 6202500033 (6793382051), v3
- 6203400009 (6799998232), v2
- Taco Bell (6817790732), v4
- Pyramid Travel (6841099472), v2
- Galva Post Office (1652205159), v4
- BG's Bar and Grill (3174113361), v3
- 5970241329, v4
- Absolute Audio (6084357446), v2
- Nuts And Bolts (6103745855), v2
- 6576874466, v2
- 6030100136 (6576874467), v2
- Classy Threads (6636537944), v2
- Mike's Towing (6691023528), v2
- 620250045 (6753388147), v3
- FedEx (6785810154), v2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |