Changeset: 65237715
completed various waterways: l'Elnon, la Gare, rui de Roteleux, courant de l'Hôpital
Closed by wuff57
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (14460 en_GB) |
---|---|
source | BD Carthage;BDOrtho IGN |
Discussion
-
Comment from Truchin
Je me demande quel est ton critère de basculement rivière/ruisseau ? Le wiki n'est pas très explicite à ce sujet.
-
Comment from wuff57
Not sure what you are refering to, as I made a number of changes in this change set. If you mean the course of l'Elnon: I used the BD Carthage layer in JOSM. Please check also the note that I added in the relation. If you meant something else, please give me a specific way as an example.
-
Comment from wuff57
It just occurred to me that you may be referring to the difference between waterway=stream and waterway=river. The French OSM wiki is not really specific about it. The English version is more specific: "the commonly accepted rule for OpenStreetMap is that a stream can be jumped across by an active, able-bodied person", but still there is a lot of judgement when you base your mapping on satellite pictures.
-
Comment from Truchin
Oui c'est cela.
En pratique, un "courant" est un ruisseau pour des français. Donc je pense qu'il faudrait élever quelque peu ton critère de passage de ruisseau à rivière. Ou simplement te référer à la BD Carthage qui comporte une classification de ce type.
Bonne continuation -
Comment from wuff57
You mentioned BD Carthage for the distinction between waterway=stream vs. river. I only have a rough understanding of BD Carthage. I'm grateful if you could tell me where exactly this can be found. I am only aware of the CLASSE field which expresses the length of the "cours d'eau", while "stream" and "river" are rather about the width of the waterway.
-
Comment from Truchin
Je comprends mieux l'allemand que l'anglais....
J'avoue me baser sur les représentations habituelles de la BD Ortho http://tile.openstreetmap.fr/?zoom=12&lat=47.7643&lon=0.46378&layers=00B0000FTFFFF ou des cartes d'état major. Franchement, la largeur n'est pas un critère suffisant pour faire la différence entre rivière et ruisseau
- 653147840, v1
- 653147841, v1
- Courant du Gros Caillou (653147842), v1
- Courant de l'Hôpital (653147843), v1
- 653147844, v1
- Ruisseau de Roteleux (653147845), v1
- Ruisseau de Roteleux (653147846), v1
- Ruisseau de Roteleux (653147847), v1
- Ruisseau de Roteleux (653147848), v1
- Ruisseau de Roteleux (653147849), v1
- 653147850, v1
- 653147851, v1
- 653147852, v1
- Ruisseau de Roteleux (653147853), v1
- L'Elnon (653147854), v1
- 653147855, v1
- Courant de Pont (653147856), v1
- Courant de Pont (653147857), v1
- Courant de Pont (653147858), v1
- Courant de Pont (653147859), v1
Relations (1-20 of 30)
- 1
- 2
- Courant de l'Hôpital (9083480), v1
- Ruisseau de Roteleux (9083481), v1
- La Gare (9083482), v1
- L'Elnon (9083483), v1
- Nord (7400), v413
- Nord-Pas-de-Calais (8648), v512
- België / Belgique / Belgien (52411), v855
- Lecelles (56422), v36
- Rumegies (57867), v18
- Mouchin (57981), v18
- Communauté française (78967), v554
- France - Belgique / België / Belgien (90341), v282
- Wallonie (90348), v570
- Hainaut (157559), v270
- België / Belgique / Belgien (land mass) (937244), v477
- France métropolitaine (1403916), v565
- Lille (1643919), v36
- Rumes (2162968), v22
- 059-06 (2187110), v22
- Tournai (2198998), v52
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |