Changeset: 53129924
Toll
Closed by IMPARGO
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (12921 de) |
---|---|
source | ASFINAG |
Discussion
-
Comment from Harald Hartmann
Hello IMPARGO. With this and other changesets you have introduced the new and so far unkown key `toll:special`. What is it for?
And according to `source` you have used some data of ASFINAG. Can you give us some information about the licence?Your recent changesets look like an import or mechanical edit, so where is it discussed and/or documented?
-
Comment from IMPARGO
Hi Harald Hartmann,
sorry for the confusion I am pretty new to the OSM community. I am trying to build a toll calculator for trucks. In Germany, Switzerland and Austria the regular toll roads are already tagged like described in the wiki (http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/DE:Key:toll). However, there are some special exceptions which have special rates. I tagged the exceptions with toll:special:NAME where NAME is the name of the toll route.
Note that the section for which the special toll is charged often a bit longer the the road with only the tag name:NAME. Thus sometimes adding the name also under the tag toll:special:NAME seems redundant but can be necessary to find out which parts of the road actually belong to the special toll exception.
Do you think this makes sense, should I add some documentation on the tag to the wiki or change it?
Regards,
Julian -
Comment from Harald Hartmann
Hello Julian,
first of all i think you should revert all your changes, probably the DWG does it. Yes it sounds hard but it's a community driven project.
Then you should read
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Guidelines
and
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct
e.g. instead of tagging each way with toll:special you also could create a relation, but if this is the better way i don't know, so this should be discussed with the community. -
Comment from IMPARGO
Hi,
thanks for your help. I wrote a short post in the discussion board. Depending on the discussion I'll then probably revert the changes and look for another/more suitable way.
- Inntal Autobahn (4393630), v25
- Inntal Autobahn (4439254), v19
- Inntal Autobahn (4439255), v32
- Inntal Autobahn (4439258), v21
- Inntal Autobahn (4439259), v21
- Inntal Autobahn (4439261), v19
- Inntal Autobahn (4531645), v49
- Inntal Autobahn (4531646), v41
- Inntal Autobahn (4773134), v18
- Inntal Autobahn (4789487), v25
- Inntal Autobahn (4789488), v27
- Inntal Autobahn (4789489), v14
- Inntal Autobahn (4789490), v14
- Inntal Autobahn (4789512), v27
- Inntal Autobahn (4789513), v25
- Inntal Autobahn (4789514), v14
- Inntal Autobahn (4789515), v11
- Inntal Autobahn (4814767), v20
- Inntal Autobahn (4814768), v20
- Inntal Autobahn (4814769), v16
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |