Changeset: 44128900
Set Wikidata ID for admin_levels, matching them with wikipedia tags
Closed by nyuriks
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (11223 en) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from escada
Please do not set the same wikipedia & wikidata tag to admin_level 8 & 9 instances. E.g. https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q102728?uselang=en-US refers to Ieper (gemeente/stad) including "deelgemeente", so clearly admin_level 8
-
Comment from nyuriks
Escada, unless there is a more specific Wikidata item, why can't multiple objects reference the same Wikidata item? I would like to avoid that, but it is still better to have a link that allows cross-db analysis, than to not have anything. I looked through OSM wiki about wikidata tag, and nothing there implies 1:1. After all, a wikidata item that contains a link to a set of wikipedia articles would be relevant for both levels.
-
Comment from escada
The items with level 8 & 9 represent different objects. Why would they get the same wikipedia/wikidata values ? It's clear that the wikidata item refers to the admin_level 8, so why bother adding one to admin_level 9 ?
This is the same as saying " there is no wikidata ID for a town, let's use the one of the country until there is a more specific item". This makes no sense. When there is no wikidata item for something, we should not take the ID of an enclosing region.
Of course you did not notice, because the wikipedia page on the admin_level 9 was also wrong imho. It describes the admin_level 8.
Another problem with your automated addition of wikidata tags is that you did not notice that the wikipedia page of a certain town was changed to a disambiguation page (after the wikipedia tag was added to the OSM object).
- Knokke-Heist (4569), v37
- Richterich (21919), v23
- Laurensberg (21920), v59
- Saint-Gilles - Sint-Gillis (58248), v15
- Ixelles - Elsene (58250), v13
- Etterbeek (58252), v10
- Uccle - Ukkel (58253), v19
- Koekelberg (58256), v6
- Ganshoren (58257), v5
- Jette (58258), v8
- Schaerbeek - Schaarbeek (58260), v11
- Saint-Josse-ten-Noode - Sint-Joost-ten-Node (58262), v9
- Auderghem - Oudergem (58263), v12
- Watermael-Boitsfort - Watermaal-Bosvoorde (58264), v13
- Berchem-Sainte-Agathe - Sint-Agatha-Berchem (60140), v12
- Evere (60144), v10
- Woluwe-Saint-Lambert - Sint-Lambrechts-Woluwe (60167), v11
- Woluwe-Saint-Pierre - Sint-Pieters-Woluwe (60168), v10
- Zwijndrecht (60887), v13
- Burcht (60888), v14
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |