Changeset: 36985172
Duplicate items removed
Closed by joejwall
Tags
build | 2.4-16-g0c126d0 |
---|---|
created_by | Potlatch 2 |
version | 2.4 |
Discussion
-
Comment from Colin Smale
Hi, I think you are probably not aware of this, but some of your recent changesets have been damaging some admin boundaries, particularly between Walmer and Ringwould civil parishes. I fixed it last week and will fix them up this time again, but please be careful in the future.....
-
Comment from Colin Smale
actually this whole changeset has caused a lot of problems. Please remember that OSM is not your private map, it is a globally shared resource. If you are not sure what you are doing, please ask for help!
-
Comment from joejwall
OK sorry about that - the admin boundary was a mistake but everything else was either very out of date or just duplicating information already on the OS Opendata Streetview making use of the map elsewhere very messy.
-
Comment from Colin Smale
Hi Joe, thanks for getting in touch. I notice you have deleted a lot of stuff in the past few weeks, as well as adding new stuff. Are you aware you have just about obliterated Ringwould in this changeset? You have deleted almost all the roads and possibly many other things...
Please ask for help to repair the damage, which you can visualise here: https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=36985172
A good place to start is probably the talk-gb mailing list which you can join from here: https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb
I have already flagged this changeset up, so hopefully some admin type will be able to sort it out this time.
Regards, Colin -
Comment from Colin Smale
Joe, I just reread your comment... Are you possibly thinking OSM is (just) an overlay to OS Streetview? You should see it as an alternative, with a complete dataset. So deleting stuff from OSM because it also appears in other maps is not the way to go.
-
Comment from joejwall
Hi Colin
I do not agree. Firstly I have not touched Ringwould. I did delete duplicate roads in Kingsdown. Why would anyone add an extra layer of roads identical to the ones already appearing on the OS Opendata Streetview layer. If I am missing something there an explanation of why such duplication is necessary would be more likely to facilitate my understanding and then possible acceptance of your comments that I should "repair the damage" when I see no point in having the extra data in the first place. Please advise.
Joe -
Comment from Colin Smale
I stand corrected, I meant Kingsdown (near the coast). As for your question about the duplication, please refer to http://www.openstreetmap.org/about . OSM is standalone, not an addon to OSSV (or any other map for that matter). Apart from that, when you are thinking about deleting other people's hard work, you might consider contacting them first to understand their rationale for adding it in the first place...
-
Comment from Gregory Williams
This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 37014168 where the changeset comment is: Revert deletions made in changeset 36985172 in the Kingsdown area
-
Comment from Gregory Williams
The JOSM reverter doesn't seem to be working at the moment, so I've used Frederick Ramm's perl reverter script to perform the revert. A few relations seem to have been edited since (presumably the coastline). I've taken a cursory glance through the boundaries and route relations and they seem to be OK, but I'll try to sanity check the data in more depth after work tonight.
- 395889181, v1
- 99836182, v3
- ER22 (99836173), v3
- 99836175, v2
- 102371968, v4
- 102371970, v2
- Kingsdown Road (155775675), v4
- 155775687, v2
- 155775691, v2
- ER7 (49431752), v5
- 49431759, v4
- 49431756, v5
- 61732442, v2
- 84060611, v3
- ER292 (84060614), v7
- 168001312, v2
- ER3 (168001310), v3
- Victoria Road (Track) (395120408), v3
- ER7 (277932899), v3
- ER23 (395120407), v3
Relations (11)
- Kent (88071), v163
- South East (151304), v658
- Ringwould with Kingsdown CP (2602515), v8
- Saxon Shore Way (8864), v317
- Walmer CP (2599220), v6
- Via Romea Francigena - part United Kingdom (2842302), v62
- Dover (1481934), v84
- Kent (4001748), v10
- Kent (172385), v178
- NCN National Route 1 (75880), v521
- South East (3820651), v188
- 3986893846, v1
- 3986893847, v1
- 3986893848, v1
- 3986893849, v1
- 3986893850, v1
- 255890768, v2
- 27412792, v2
- 3526165516, v2
- 1681360981, v2
- Jarvist Place (502554648), v2
- Village Hall (3791596480), v3
- CT14 85 (894153440), v2
- 627875155, v2
- 3426554842, v2
- 1154174635, v3
- 769158938, v2
- 2206309732, v2
- 1154174673, v2
- 627875149, v2
- 2918473115, v3
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |