Changeset: 31222847
fix wikipedia links and josm warnings/errors
Closed by Med
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (8339 en_GB) |
---|---|
source | osmose+josm |
Discussion
-
Comment from Zbigniew_Cz
What is that change? Where was discussed?
-
Comment from Med
Hello Zbigniew,
The errors have been identified with the osmose tool: http://osmose.openstreetmap.fr/en/map/ . The fixes are detailed here and follow the OSM guidelines: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Osmose/issues (search wikipedia in the page). In the present case the issue was that the links were listed aa "wikipedia:pl=article" when they should have been "wikipedia=pl:article".
Regards,
Med
-
Comment from Zbigniew_Cz
OK, but what about e.g. that case? http://osm.mapki.com/history/node.php?id=31889156
Every village in Poland has own wikipage in polish wikipedia, e.g. https://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pielgrzymowice_%28wojew%C3%B3dztwo_ma%C5%82opolskie%29
In this case should be add wikipedia=pl:* instead replace wikipedia:en= -> wikipedia= -
Comment from Zbigniew_Cz
I mean: "replace wikipedia:en= -> wikipedia=en:*"
-
Comment from Med
Hello Zbigniew,
I do not add new tags. I mean if there is a wikipedia:en=article, I transform it into a wikipedia=en:article. The issue here is that there was no pl link already. That being said I fully agree with your point. I will try to submit the idea to the osmose developers to see whether they can add a test when there is already an article present in the local language. I have seen the issue a bit all over the place in Poland. Maybe you want to raise the issue with the Polish community to fix that?
Regards,
Med
-
Comment from Zbigniew_Cz
OK, but I think you should consult your plans with polish community BEFORE change.
-
Comment from Med
Hello Zbigniew,
Just to clarify, I do not have any plan about pl:. Whether the Polish community wants to use pl: rather than en: or not is completely up to them and independent from my corrections. I merely agreed that it would make more sense to favour pl: in Poland (even though technically any link in any language is fine). My corrections are simply about using the correct format as documented on the wiki: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:wikipedia (whether it is en:, pl: or anything else does not matter). At any rate, I do not plan to do additional corrections around Poland for a while. Let me know if I can help later on.
Regards,
Med
Ways (14)
- 259346675, v3
- Akademia Muzyczna (202158950), v3
- Bazylika pw. św. Ludwika Króla i Wniebowzięcia Najświętszej Maryi Panny (201578529), v7
- Factory Centrum (Browar Mokrskich) (254116867), v4
- 202209203, v4
- Kościół pw. św. Jadwigi Śląskiej w Katowicach-Szopienicach (201898166), v4
- Kościół świętego Szczepana (202032357), v6
- Kuria Metropolitalna (202150647), v6
- Most autostradowy w Mszanie (166157536), v13
- Most autostradowy w Mszanie (166157537), v15
- Muzeum Śląskie (202259267), v4
- Podzamcze (289299814), v4
- Stary Dworzec Kolejowy (202259447), v5
- Szotkówka (267215199), v4
- Borowce (31902738), v11
- Bronów (31937165), v16
- Brzezówka (31937111), v12
- Bukowno (31902609), v13
- Błażejowice (259427981), v13
- Celiny (31902560), v12
- Celiny (1233294728), v4
- Chałupki (3009695458), v4
- Chałupki (31902543), v14
- Chorzenice (31902486), v13
- Cielętniki (31902458), v12
- Cisowa (31902438), v12
- Cynków (31902424), v13
- Czekanów (388402695), v11
- Czyżowice (31936856), v16
- Dobieszowice (343158981), v14
- Drochlin (31902314), v13
- Gołkowice (31936642), v11
- Gołuchowice (418002049), v6
- Gołuchowice (31902193), v12
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |