Changeset: 140246163
KY: Migrating and normalizing GNIS ID synonym (gnis:id,PLACENS) to gnis:feature_id as discussed here https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/cleanup-and-normalization-of-gnis-imports-to-only-use-gnis-feature-id-for-the-id-tag/101031
Closed by watmildon
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18789 en) |
---|---|
source | Bing |
Discussion
-
Comment from mbe57
This normalization ended up with a bank that has a population of nearly 7000?
-
Comment from watmildon
Hello! I presume you're interested in this node (https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/153943762/history). If that's not the case let me know.
The data error you mention predates my cleanup work but definitely points to something being wrong. My best guess is the error was introduced in this changeset (https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/34636544) by merging perviously overlapping bank and place nodes. The bank information and place information appear to have been re-added independently leaving this as an extra (and erroneous?) node.
I have move the extra bank tags to the bank and adjusted the county relation to use the other place node as the "admin_centre". Does that seem right to you? https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/145050802
-
Comment from mbe57
Spot on, thank you, watmildon.
I stumbled into this bank item when rebuilding the dataset for settlements, in preparation for re-rendering them for the openandromaps.org world maps.
TXs for the quick response and resolution.
Cheers
Michael
Ways (15)
- 34157429, v8
- 34160245, v3
- 34162802, v3
- Latonia Terrace (123060981), v9
- 123060987, v13
- Rabbit Hash (260754323), v4
- 331002131, v3
- 331002132, v3
- 331002136, v3
- Stone Hedge Estates (681287748), v5
- Indian Hills (681454309), v5
- Washpan Lake (707047910), v2
- 880018721, v2
- 880018722, v2
- Immaculate Conception Church (903119971), v2
- Dry Ridge (130322), v6
- Taylor Mill (130324), v10
- Fairview (130325), v5
- Park Hills (130326), v9
- Ludlow (130327), v13
- Lakeside Park (130328), v5
- Kenton Vale (130329), v5
- Fort Wright (130330), v9
- Fort Mitchell (130331), v10
- Crestview Hills (130332), v6
- Edgewood (130334), v6
- Elsmere (130335), v6
- Bromley (130336), v8
- Covington (130337), v24
- West Point (130339), v6
- Vine Grove (130340), v6
- Wallins Creek (130347), v5
- South Wallins (130348), v5
- Lynch (130350), v7
- Pioneer Village (130354), v7
- Knottsville (153340173), v5
- Brownsville (153342186), v5
- Oak Hill (153342208), v4
- Saint Charles (153342252), v4
- Depoy (153342875), v5
- Ida (153342900), v5
- Meadow Lawn (153343369), v5
- Seneca Gardens (153343393), v8
- Smithfield (153343422), v6
- Munfordville (153343428), v6
- Indian Hills (153343447), v8
- Pinchem (153343461), v6
- Watauga (153343473), v5
- Sparksville (153343493), v5
- Benleo (153343512), v4
- Booth (153343521), v4
- Wingo (153344187), v7
- Arlington (153344275), v6
- Trenton (153344291), v7
- Vanderburg (153345211), v4
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |