Changeset: 118758879
Added Port A schools
Closed by TravGW
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18360 en) |
---|---|
source | Mapbox Satellite; National Agriculture Imagery Program |
Discussion
-
Comment from kevinp2
Hi, this changeset says "Added Port A schools" but it is a large edit to several streets including removing tags from some of them.
For example, you removed the tag of cycleway=none from Beach Street (way 833760990).
Are you possibly using software that is removing tags and deleting information without your knowledge?
-
Comment from kevinp2
This changeset also deleted a marked pedestrian crossing that exists. Way 1026246841.
-
Comment from kevinp2
Also wrongly deleted: a parking aisle, way 1015280411
-
Comment from kevinp2
Also wrongly deleted without any discussion: relation 13593435, which joins together the various parts of St. Joseph's Catholic Church compound. This took an hour of on-foot survey to create!
-
Comment from kevinp2
Wrongly removed the tag cycleway=none from Trout Street
-
Comment from kevinp2
Wrongly removed the tag cycleway=none from Cotter Avenue. These have been explicitly surveyed to make it easier to plan bike routes. Please don't delete anything that you don't understand or haven't verified.
-
Comment from kevinp2
The tag cycleway=none has been wrongly removed in this commit from several city streets that have nothing to do with "Port A" schools. The purpose of adding this tag was to clearly identify which roads did NOT have a bike path, and which roads might or might not. You have eliminated all this work.
-
Comment from TravGW
The tag deletions probably should have been in their own changeset.
Cycleway=no is usually the default and normally doesn't need to be added. I'll ask the OSM US Slack group about when to use cycleway=no.
The pedestrian crossing was not attached to any other ways making it a routing island. As such it was deleted. I'll add it back in along with the sidewalks.
The Catholic church relation was done incorrectly. They way in which it was done, made it seem as though everything but the buildings were part of the church grounds. The relation is not needed was deleted. The tags from the relation were moved onto way 1015277541.
-
Comment from kevinp2
Thanks, I appreciate your response.
In general, I would request you to not delete other users' contributions without verifying that the feature in question does not actually exist. Even if they are incomplete, they still represent reality and can be completed by the original user, or others who come along later. I have myself expanded and extended other users' basic creations.
Thanks!
- Port Aransas Independent School District (1042498482), v1
- Brundrett Middle School (1042498483), v1
- 1042498484, v1
- 1042498485, v1
- 1042498486, v1
- H. G. Olsen Elementary School (1042498487), v1
- Port Aransas High School (1042498488), v1
- 1042498489, v1
- 1042498490, v1
- Church Street (21150782), v7
- East Avenue A (21150963), v6
- Palm Drive (21151478), v9
- West Avenue A (21153090), v9
- West Avenue C (21153133), v13
- East Oakes Avenue (21153600), v8
- Beach Street (21153986), v17
- North Alister Street (21154653), v11
- North Station Street (21155307), v10
- Channel View Drive (21156104), v13
- Lantana Drive (21156602), v8
Relations (1)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |