Changeset: 118449421
Fix boundary topology issues
Closed by ZeLonewolf
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18389 en) |
---|---|
source | OSM conventions for boundaries; JOSM validator |
Discussion
-
Comment from user_8101879
Hi,
why did you add the role label for the village/town/city/suburb and not the role admin_centre ?
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Relation:boundary#Relation_members
Best regards -
Comment from ZeLonewolf
admin_centre is only used for administrative centers such as capitals and county seats. Label is used for holding the ordinary place node associated with a boundary. Typically entities below county wouldn't have an admin_centre role.
-
Comment from user_8101879
Hi,
wiki (copy/paste) = "Node representing the administrative centre (a capital, county seat etc.), usually a town, city or village (depending of the boundary level, see place=*). This role is for capitals (as in capital cities), not capitols (as in legislative buildings).""village" should be admin_centre
But I agree for "neighbourhood"If you have talked about that (or if there a talk about that) on the wiki talk for U.S. : https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-us
and if it is what the communauty has decided, no problem. But if you have made this choice alone, probably someone will change your modifications.
Best regards -
Comment from ZeLonewolf
Yes, it was discussed on the tagging list, most recently in Oct 2021.
A village would not typically be the "capital" of a city or town.
-
Comment from ZeLonewolf
To elaborate, simply assigning the node associated with the most prominent built-up area of a city or town the admin_label role is not good geodata. admin_label specifically represents a capital/territory relationship.
-
Comment from ZeLonewolf
Typo... meant "admin_centre" in comment above.
-
Comment from user_8101879
Maybe you should add a link to the talk in your future changesets because I think many users don't know this specific rule for your country and it will prevent (or try to prevent) that some people change these roles
Best regards -
Comment from ZeLonewolf
This isn't a rule specific to the US, though of course capital/territory relationships will be quite different from country to country. In any case, I would expect that any contributor working in a country other than their own to have the responsibility of understanding what the local conventions are.
- 146478595, v3
- 146478597, v3
- 146478606, v6
- 146478617, v3
- 146478621, v2
- 146478622, v2
- 146478631, v3
- 146478635, v2
- 146478636, v3
- 146478640, v2
- 146478641, v4
- 146481527, v4
- 146481528, v2
- 146481529, v2
- 146481531, v3
- 146481532, v2
- 146481534, v2
- 146481535, v4
- 146481536, v4
- 146504107, v5
- Bartow (117719), v12
- Fort Meade (117722), v10
- Mulberry (117734), v10
- Carrabelle (117737), v11
- LaBelle (117738), v9
- Brooksville (117741), v11
- Royal Palm Beach (117922), v11
- Wellington (117924), v15
- Port Orange (117926), v14
- Pierson (117927), v11
- Ormond Beach (117928), v16
- Orange City (117930), v10
- Lake Helen (117934), v9
- Chattahoochee (1212761), v16
- Paxton (1212773), v9
- Caryville (1214011), v11
- Ebro (1214012), v15
- White Springs (1214412), v10
- Avon Park (1216575), v8
- Atlantis (1216576), v7
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |