OpenStreetMap

Mapping Center Turn Lanes in the United States

Posted by mvexel on 3 October 2017 in English (English)

When I moved to the United States six years ago, center turn lanes were a new thing to me. Two Way Left Turn Lanes (TWLTL) , as they are officially called, make traffic safer on busy roads where left turns are made frequently, by offering a dedicated lane for left turns:

design Source: MUTCD

When I first started to map these lanes, there was no documentation on the OpenStreetMap wiki on them, so I just started to map ways that have them with center_turn_lane=yes, thinking that I'd revisit them later if the community came up with more sensible tagging scheme.

In 2012, infamous US mapper NE2 created a page dedicated to TWCTL, adopting the British spelling centre_turn_lane=yes. There are around 6000 uses of this tag, most of them in the United States. The page was created without much if any discussion in the US community: there is only one reference to it on the talk-us mailing list[1].

Since 2012, more elaborate tools and tagging schemes have emerged to map lane configurations. I particularly like the Turn Lanes Editor JOSM plugin which, together with the Lane and Road Information paint style, offers an intuitive and visual way to add lane details to ways.

josm

As you can see, when a two-lane road with a TWLTL is tagged using the plugin, the map paint style offers the correct interpretation. The tags on this way would be as follows:

lanes=3; lanes:forward=1; lanes:backward=1; lanes:both_ways=1; turn:lanes:both_ways=left

Even though this looks much more complicated than just centre_turn_lane=yes, the plugin makes it straightforward to map (it even remembers recently used configurations so you can easily apply to other ways) and it uses the generic lanes tagging schema that is already in wide use, and allows for tagging even the most complex lane configurations.

TWLTL have been a topic of discussion in the Telenav mapping team. We have been adding a lot of lane configuration details in Detroit and Phoenix. For now, I gave the team the following guidance:

  • For ways that don't have TWLTL tagging yet, use the plugin and the generic lanes / turn:lanes schema.
  • Where (local) mappers have already added centre_turn_lane tagging, leave it alone.

I would rather have one consistent tagging style for the United States (and other countries where TWLTLs are common. I would prefer to use the lanes / turn:lanes tagging for that. What do you think?

[1] The OSM mailing lists are notoriously hard to search. I used wget -r -np -l 1 -q -A gz https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-us/ && find . -name \*.gz -exec gunzip {} + && find . -name \*.txt -exec cat {} + | grep centre_turn_lane

Comment from skquinn on 3 October 2017 at 19:03

I'm in favor of the lanes/turn:lanes syntax, if only because that's the style used by the current plugin and it allows for center lane uses other than left (or right) turns.

What we are really missing is a consistent way to tag reversible lanes, either as a center lane or such as those found in the Houston area as HOV/HOT lanes. The syntax used by the plugin isn't recognized by the map paint style, the default rendering style doesn't seem to do anything special for oneway=reversible, and that tag seems to confuse a lot of tools.

Hide this comment

Comment from Paul Johnson on 3 October 2017 at 19:19

In general I change the centre_turn_lane=* or center_turn_lane=* tagging to the more widely used turn:lanes tag.

Hide this comment

Comment from DevonshireBoy42 on 3 October 2017 at 19:27

Just remember that in the UK (and some other countries) the final tag would become turn:lanes:both_ways=right

Hide this comment

Comment from Minh Nguyen on 3 October 2017 at 20:59

Just discovered the lanes:both_ways and turn:lanes:both_ways tags over the weekend โ€“ this is much better than cent{er,re}_turn_lane. ๐Ÿ‘

The OSM mailing lists are notoriously hard to search.

It used to be a lot easier when Gmaneโ€™s Web interface was still around. If you use a newsreader like Thunderbird, you can subscribe to gmane.comp.gis.openstreetmap.region.us and search threads using the built-in search function.

Hide this comment

Comment from Paul Johnson on 4 October 2017 at 05:24

Looking at that example screenshot, kind of leads more support to my theory that it's time we start tagging for where the parking strip and bicycle lanes are on the street in order to provide correct lane guidance.

Hide this comment

Comment from andygol on 4 October 2017 at 06:04

I would rather have one consistent tagging style for the United States (and other countries where TWLTLs are common. I would prefer to use the lanes / turn:lanes tagging for that. What do you think?

@mvexel I support you on your willingness to have consistency in the data in the US and around the world.

As you see on the screenshot, turn:lanes:both_ways tag has three values: for the left or right turn and for the case when the center lane is used for reversible driving. It is much clearer tagging then just cent{er,re}_turn_lane=yes (and I just like namespace approach ๐Ÿ˜).

@mvexel what you think about adding this task to MapRoulette or to-fix?

Hide this comment

Comment from TheSwavu on 4 October 2017 at 22:44

I use The Mail Archive to search the OSM mail lists:

https://www.mail-archive.com/talk-us@openstreetmap.org/msg00000.html

In fact, something as obscure as centre_turn_lane you can search all their mail lists:

https://www.mail-archive.com/search?l=all&q=centre_turn_lane

Hide this comment

Leave a comment

Parsed with Markdown

  • Headings

    # Heading
    ## Subheading

  • Unordered list

    * First item
    * Second item

  • Ordered list

    1. First item
    2. Second item

  • Link

    [Text](URL)
  • Image

    ![Alt text](URL)

Login to leave a comment