OpenStreetMap

A look into a sample of edits from MAPS.ME contributors from November

Posted by manoharuss on 1 December 2016 in English (English)

As a follow up to our previous reviews of Maps.me user edits, these are the Maps.me issues we have observed during the month of November during validation using OSMCha. Documenting the errors observed can initiate a conversation on improving user experience, information to the users, characteristics of mapping activity from users. This in turn improves OSM.

Summary

  • Reviewed: 1078 CSV
  • Suspicious changesets: 46
  • No issues: 1032

We commented on these changesets:

  • Added my home in the name tag: 1
  • Added 76 fuel_stations: 1
  • Added ton of outdoor shops: 1
  • Added attractions for address and buildings: 1
  • Added amenity=school for bus stops, canteen, parking lot due to the presence of an adjacent school building: 1
  • Added Korean names in the name:en tag: 1
  • Added attraction tag for addresses: 1
  • Added description in the name tag: 1
  • Added ton of sports shops and other POIs: 1 - Cleanup
  • Added 101 benches: 1
  • Added 133 confectionery shops: 1

Community members commented on these changesets:

  • Wrong naming to the tags: 1
  • Irrelavent information: 1
  • Added personal name to the supermarket: 1
  • missed religion tag but in name:ru tag pointed that this is Ukrainian church: 1
  • Added numbers to the name tag: 1

Reverted changesets:

  • Added many view points: 1, 2
  • Added weird names for post offices like 'Timber', 'Hostel', 'Grocery': 1
  • Added convenience shops at the same place: 1
  • Adding virus in the name tag of all the neighborhoods in Vietnam: 1
  • Added number of bus stops together: 1
  • Duplicate POI's, community reverted the changeset: 1, 2, 3
  • Added number of view points with same name: 1
  • Added numbers to the name tag: 1

Observations:

It would be great if the community comes together, share thoughts and ideas to help the developers fix these issues in future. Issues can be filed in the Maps.me repository.

From,

Chetan, Krishna & Manohar

Login to leave a comment