Ashley Heath needs map love

Posted by Steve Chilton on 14 September 2009 in English (English)

I was bigging up OSM at the Society of Cartographers conference last week. Today I got an email from a delegate saying "yeh, you say that - but my village has no detail at all". Indeed, Ashley Heath (nr Market Drayton) had just the cross roads. So just now I have added all the roads that are clearly visible on the NPE layer (tagged as highway=road), and a couple of footpaths (highway=path). I will shortly end the person a Walking Papers geo-rectified printout and ask them to collaborate by adding in the newer roads and adding road names etc, (which I will edit happily). Is anyone local able to verify stuff on the ground - the roads need classifying for instance. Most are probably residential/unclassified, but might be tracks, etc. I see that user:pepperm added the local pub this very day. Perhaps you could contact me (have sent a personal msg too). It would be good to show the power of the crowd in this kind of scenario.


Comment from Richard on 15 September 2009 at 09:43

That looks better. Have to wean you off using "highway=road" though - in this sort of area it's almost certainly going to be highway=unclassified, and it's much more useful to have a 95% guess (which someone can come and correct in the 5% case) than such an unspecific tag!

Comment from Mappo on 16 September 2009 at 11:05

I'd suggest a bit of reverse psychology is in order. Instead of the message being "OSM is perfect and already finished" which clearly it isn't, you can spin it as "OSM only has a few untouched spots available in the UK, this is your last chance to get the satisfaction of being the first one to sketch out a blank area".

You're still emphasising progress, but finding a blank spot is seen as a good thing. From comments here and elsewhere there are a variety of things that drive contributors but one strong motivation is "filling in the gaps". Maybe it's better to leave these for the newbies to get them started?

Login to leave a comment