OpenStreetMap

The Search for a Solution

Posted by Amna A on 19 June 2019 in English. Last updated on 24 June 2019.

Last summer I was deployed for the Humanitarian OpenStreetMap Team (HOT) Uganda project and wanted to share an account of some of my time in the field.

My past two years working on global health and development in the epicenter of the field - Washington, D.C. - gave me a good understanding of the refugee crisis and the problems faced by displaced populations around the world. Or so I had thought.

There are currently estimated to be ~1.4 million refugees in Uganda. It is here that, after a 25 hour flight with two layovers and multiple anti-nausea tablets, I arrived, eager to work with the Humanitarian OpenStreetMap Team (HOT) to promote the mapping of refugee environments for humanitarian purposes.

I spent my first few days getting oriented in the HOT office in Kampala, and thoroughly enjoying all the city has to offer (rolex stands need to make their way to the States, pronto!). We then headed north to Arua where the huge settlements of Rhino and Imvepi are located.

Commercial PhotographyCommercial Photography Shamillah and Allan, my amazing partners in crime

In Arua, our task was simple – we train refugee students and teachers on the OpenStreetMap (OSM) platform and mobile data collection in three secondary schools: Ofua Secondary School, Rhino High School, and Imvepi Secondary School. We set off from Kampala at 10 AM on Tuesday. Two car breakdowns, a driving ticket, a taxi, and 15 hours later, Shamillah, Allan, and I finally arrived.

Commercial Photography Pushing our broken car out of the road!

Over time, I have come to value experience over theory. No amount of rote knowledge can replace the understanding your senses provide you. Read all the poetry in the world, but until you experience love, you do not know what it means to find home in another being. Study music theory all you want, but it can never invoke the feeling of transcendence that the sound of a sitar brings with it. The refugee crisis is no exception. Nothing prepared me for witnessing the aftermath of the mass migration of people fleeing war and conflict.

A bit more about HOT’s mission before I continue: HOT, through training local communities and authorities, promotes the utilization of OSM. This is a free ‘wiki’-style map, which can be used by anybody with a log-in to trace and tag satellite imagery from various sources to help identify important features of any area, contributing to a fully mapped globe. HOT also utilizes a mobile application called OpenDataKit (ODK), which surveyors use to collect GPS coordinates and attributes of various points of interests (i.e. schools, hospitals, water points, latrines, etc.) that are then fed into OpenStreetMap for public consumption. Introducing these tools to refugee schools was something I was particularly excited about because they not only exposed refugee communities to new technology, but also provided them with a sense of ownership and accountability of their living and work spaces.

Commercial Photography Trying to explain GPS coordinates to students. I thought I was making sense…

Shamilah, Allan, and I spent the next three days visiting the schools and training both teachers and students on these two facets of our work. Our first training site, Afua Secondary School, presented the unique challenge of working (in ICT) without a power source. Since we were not able to project the website and guide the trainees as easily as we would’ve liked, Allan improvised, using his amazing drawing skills to replicate the web interface on the chalkboard and direct the students that way. Luckily, power was available at our next site, Rhino High School, so we were able to use the projector. I still remember the energy in the room when we searched for the students’ hometown in South Sudan, Yei, on OSM. Hope, pain, longing, and awe all pervaded through the class as we virtually walked through the streets of Yei. Re-energized by the enthusiasm, we returned to the camps the next day for our final training only to find that due to miscommunication amongst staff members of Imvepi Secondary School, time had not been allotted for our visit - we unfortunately had to leave without training the students at that location…

I gathered my thoughts during our twelve hour bus ride back to Kampala, the city that had now become home. What exactly was I feeling? It took some mental poking and prodding but I finally pinpointed it to be frustration. We had just spent three days introducing interesting, helpful, and hopeful technology to students who it seemed many times did not even have access to power, much less computer labs. A one-off training in these circumstances would be limited in its ability to leave a lasting impact. Ignorance is bliss they say. Would introducing laptops and cellphones and selfies, opening these students’ eyes to such resources without a means to access in the future be doing more damage than good? After conversing with my team members about some of my reservations, I realized how aware HOT is of these issues and all it is doing to increase the sustainability of its work and its impact on the global community. HOT spends every last penny to continue these trainings, get people mapping for their own purposes, introduce this system to the NGO world, and skill citizens for employment. Furthermore, there is greater accessibility to mobile phones amongst refugee populations than I originally assumed. But it is still a battle.

Commercial Photography Selfie time! The students absolutely loved being able to take pictures

Integration of the various humanitarian efforts underway in Uganda is a big first step to creating more sustainable benefits to the refugee community. While all humanitarian coordination in Uganda goes, in theory, through one channel, UNHCR, an increase in collaboration within and between the humanitarian sectors is necessary to identify needs which are not being met, and to direct resources in a more strategic manner.

There must be a greater push to coordinate efforts if we truly want to make a difference in refugee communities. Some of HOT’s maps of ‘community-witnessed services’ are now on the UNHCR Coordination Web Portal. HOT’s mapping endeavors, if properly utilized, are very helpful in identifying problems in the settlements that need to be taken into consideration when planning resource distribution. If the humanitarian sector at large adapts HOT’s maps into its planning process, there is the potential to greatly reduce the inconsistencies in aid dispersal and increase the impact interventions have in refugee communities.

One last note: seeing and hearing Ugandans’ warm and welcoming attitude towards refugees was such a breath of fresh air. I found Uganda to be a far less antagonistic host country than America, both in policy and in practice, despite its greater limitation on resources. America could learn a thing or two from Uganda on how to approach displaced populations…

Commercial Photography All smiles outside Rhino Camp High School

Location: Isakua, Oluko, Arua, Northern Region, Uganda

Discussion

Comment from pedrito1414 on 19 June 2019 at 22:27

Hi Amna, thanks for sharing your experience! Really nice read… Be great to share your diary with the HOT community directly. Are you on the HOT mailing list or slack?

https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot https://slack.hotosm.org/

Comment from RAytoun on 22 June 2019 at 12:00

Thank you Amna for your eye witness account and experiences. This sort of feedback is very helpful in getting the remote mappers to understand the need for mapping. If you have any photographs of the villages, buildings and roads these would be very helpful as well for the validators and mappers.

Comment from Amna A on 23 June 2019 at 17:05

Hi Raytoun! I actually do not have more photos but I know that the HOT Uganda team has plenty. Here is there FB page: https://web.facebook.com/hotosmuganda/?_rdc=1&_rdr and I am sure if you contact them, they would be able to provide more.

Comment from amapanda ᚛ᚐᚋᚐᚅᚇᚐ᚜ 🏳️‍🌈 on 24 June 2019 at 12:20

This blog post contains a photo of someone giving a “f*** you” sign to the reader. Please edit it to remove such an abrasive sign, and please try to have a bit more decorum in future.

Comment from Kateregga1 on 24 June 2019 at 13:11

Hi Amna, thank you so much for sharing your experience in the field with us in Uganda.

@rorym I think the sign from Allan in the photo is the V peace sign. I don’t see it as abrasive!

Comment from pedrito1414 on 24 June 2019 at 13:48

Agree with Kateregga1 on the V sign. I have seen it used with different meanings in different cultures.

Comment from Amna A on 24 June 2019 at 14:02

@Kateregga1 and @pedrito1414 Thank you - would have to agree as well; I think intentionality is always key and I know Allan was not intending to convey that with that hand gesture.

Comment from amapanda ᚛ᚐᚋᚐᚅᚇᚐ᚜ 🏳️‍🌈 on 24 June 2019 at 14:14

Yes it is not insulting in some cultures, but it is in some cultures. Doesn’t HOT claim to be nice and friendly and better than that. Is including this image really the hill you want to die on? Just change it and move on.

Comment from pedrito1414 on 24 June 2019 at 15:40

Hi Rory, you seem suddenly very angry in your comment… I’m not sure where this has come from…

I also don’t know what most of that last comment really means (or what the italics represent)…

It would be great if you could assume good intent in a diary like this and keep responses constructive. There is really no need for this discussion to escalate to being unpleasant or accusatory.

Comment from amapanda ᚛ᚐᚋᚐᚅᚇᚐ᚜ 🏳️‍🌈 on 24 June 2019 at 19:35

This image has been changed. Thanks Amna. FTR I never thought you (or the subject) were intentionally being insulting. But “Intent isn’t magic” is part of Code of Conduct 101. (Also “Assume Good Intent” helps abusers)

@pedrito1414 in all comments I had constructive suggestions, and initally said “Please”. We can add gas lighting to your tone policing.

Comment from TheDude05 on 16 July 2019 at 19:15

In some cultures smiling means negative intentions, does that mean we need to remove all photos of people smiling? Some cultures don’t like photographs of people, should we not post pictures at all? You may have said please but you couched the photo in antagonistic terms and thus left a bitter taste in some mouths. Perhaps in the future you might send a message to the author about it rather than post it in the comments, which really should be about the actual content of the article rather than possible implied hand gestures as interpreted by small subsets of the global population.

Comment from techlady on 18 August 2019 at 00:37

Hi, Amna, What a wonderful piece. Not only do you write beautifully, but you are fearless in sharing your thoughts and feelings, enabling all of us to understand more deeply what is happening in Uganda. I don’t think you did any harm by exposing these young people to the world of mapping and computers. The more we raise their knowledge about the world, the more they will expect from the world. That is the way it should be, and they never should be satisfied with what they have now. Your insights also will help improve the services these people get, if only a little. But, little by little, you can help build a better world for them. Well done!

Log in to leave a comment