OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Resolved note #156063

Description

I see in history that this has been changed from having no place tag, to having a place = region, to having a place = island (which is the current value)... I think it is pretty obvious that is not an island. Since no peninsula key has been approved, my fisrt thought would be to remove this and leave the area at the city of methana as is, but I 'd appreciate a second opinion..

Created by Chris Makridis

Resolved by Chris Makridis

Location: 37.6074834, 23.3716125

This note includes comments from anonymous users which should be independently verified.

Discussion

  • Comment from Kanenas

    See if this fit you: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:natural%3Dcape

    Also you can try the old admin_level:8 boundary for Μεθανα and Τροιζήνα in addition to the existing(?) admin_level:7 of Μεθανα/Τροιζήνα combined if you just want to register the name.(http://www.dimostrizinias.gr/index.php/el/o-dimos-troizinias-methanon). **Also search queries will include Methana, Methana/Trizina in the "is_in" result for every element inside the boundary**

    Also in the peninsula's rejected proposal page (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/peninsula)
    there are some comments from the voters for an alternative taging scheme.

    MY OPINION - WAIT FOR OTHER USERS TO COMMENT!!!

  • Comment from anonymous

    I think that you are right. This is not an island.

  • Comment from jimkats

    As now it has the approved tag natural=peninsula, which of course it's the correct description for this area, I guess this note is solved.

  • Resolved by Chris Makridis

    indeed @jimkats, thanks for the heads up :)

https://openstreetmap.org/copyright https://openstreetmap.org
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license