Changeset: 99470322

Man_made=Geoglyph cleanup

Closed about 4 years ago by c tito young

changesets_count	681
created_by	iD 2.19.5
host	https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit
imagery_used	Bing aerial imagery
locale	en

Discussion

Comment from SomeoneElse about 4 years ago

Most of the items here I can't really see in the underlying imagery - https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/904857091/history being just one example.
Comment from c tito young about 4 years ago

Hi Andy,

These are not that hard to see. I use Bing Maps and look for figurative shapes. They fall into place and are very visible.

.t
Comment from SomeoneElse about 4 years ago

I tried moving the imagery significantly to one side in P3 in order to not be influenced by what you have already added. I have to see I really can't see more than the odd splodge. Perhaps in the interests of https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Verifiability we need to ask the question more widely?
Best Regards,
Andy
Comment from c tito young about 4 years ago

Hi Andy,
Thanks for your review and your hard work. The Verifiability was helpful, maybe I need to include more about how these shapes can be better recognized. These etchings can be old, faded, incomplete or clear depending one the amount of physical erosion. .. My settings are default on a 17 inch laptop screen. I will check and recheck if these holdup to the verifiability standard. Maybe if there any on/off toggle of saved work without having risk deletion?
Thanks again.
.t
Comment from c tito young about 4 years ago

Hi Andy
An update in this exact area, related to this changeset, might give you some verification and you can better see it.
Comment from SomeoneElse about 4 years ago

While there are lines more clearly visible in the updated imagery, what you have drawn does not match them.
I've tried tracing what I can see on the dev server and that got me https://api06.dev.openstreetmap.org/#map=19/-14.87584/-74.92476&layers=D . It doesn't look much like https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=19/-14.87584/-74.92476&layers=D at all.
Comment from SomeoneElse about 4 years ago

> Maybe if there any on/off toggle of saved work without having risk deletion?
When someone deletes something from OpenStreetMap in the normal way previous versions are still in the history. For example, you deleted https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/906981742/history 15 days ago, but you can still see it via an overpass query: https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/14DZ .
Comment from c tito young about 4 years ago

Hi Andy, ill try to review the the ones I made, be as close as possible with the linework, and of course be as close as any upcoming ones that I will find. BTW.. you are super helpful... thank you!!!!!!