OpenStreetMap

Restoring version 3 of way 98609930

Closed about 5 years ago by Hjart

Tags

• Comment from ma-rt-in about 5 years ago

  Hallo,
  auf welcher Grundlage wurden meine Änderungen zurückgesetzt?
  vg

• Comment from Hjart about 5 years ago

  Personal preference. I'm quite familiar with all of these stations (I've been mapping them for years) and simple lines tend to work better for routing.

• Comment from ma-rt-in about 5 years ago

  So you claim that just for the sake of better routing, it should be avoided to map platforms as area.
  I think that is a bad opinion. I would even say it would be a mapping for the evaluator.

• Comment from Hjart about 5 years ago

  Why would you map them as areas, if not for personal preference?

• Comment from ma-rt-in about 5 years ago

  I would map the platforms as a surface, as it can be seen on the satellite images. It also illustrates the extent of the platform better.

• Comment from Hjart about 5 years ago

  Simple lines illustrates them just as well.

• Comment from Hjart about 5 years ago

  Some people apparently wants to map even narrow platforms as areas. Personally I thinks it's a silly bad idea.

• Comment from ma-rt-in about 5 years ago

  However, do not allow conclusions about the width of the platform. Because it is just a dash in the landscape.
  So your argument, it would be enough, shows me that you do not want to map objects more detailed.

• Comment from Hjart about 5 years ago

  For all practical purposes, simple lines are enough.
  Please note that we map footways and roads as simple lines, because that's the only realistic way we can have functional routing.

Log in to join the discussion