Changeset: 66946951
yellowstone backcountry campsite names
Closed by giggls
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (14760 de) |
---|---|
source | add names according to https://www.nps.gov/yell/planyourvisit/upload/bctrip-planner_2018.pdf |
Discussion
-
Comment from datamongers
Im not a fan of this change, I think it makes the map less useful. Every map of Yellowstone i've ever seen that shows backcountry campsites uses whats now the ref, not the long name, The short names are also used by when booking a backcountry permit. I dont think i've seen any software that makes use of the ref tag on a campsite.
-
Comment from datamongers
i see now that there is 1 piece of software that does use the ref tags on campsites, your website.
-
Comment from giggls
Refering to other objects in Openstreetmap ref is usually the correct thing for stuff like this.
I did not invent the names. They are also called "name" in the official document I refered to in the changeset comment.
So what else would you suggest? I do not think that removing the real names from name tag alltogether would be a good idea. Actually I thought about putting the numbers into name tag in addition to what the document calls name, but frankly, that's actually what ref is for.
Sven
-
Comment from giggls
Ah, one more thing. Did you read my blogpost? http://blog.gegg.us/2019/01/announcing-open-camping-map/
Tagging of campsites in US National Parks would need a lot of love!
- Yellowstone River Trail (1197895854), v4
- Crevice Lake (1197912141), v4
- Yellowstone River Trail (1197947871), v4
- Wolf Lake (1914309234), v3
- Grebe Lake North (1914309239), v3
- Grebe Lake Outlet (1914309271), v3
- Wolf Lake Outlet (1914309273), v3
- Lone Star (3064201081), v4
- Upper Firehole (3064201082), v4
- Firehole Springs (3064201083), v4
- Mallard Lake SE (3064201084), v4
- Mallard Lake E (3064201085), v4
- Mallard Lake Outlet (3064201086), v4
- Fairy Meadows (3064201087), v4
- Firehole Meadows (3064201088), v4
- Firehole Falls (3064201089), v4
- Imperial Meadows (3064201090), v5
- Goose Lake (3064201091), v5
- Summit Lake (3064201092), v4
- Sentinel Meadows East (3064201093), v4
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |