Changeset: 108540845
Updated deprecated roof tags with building: (such as building:roof:shape) to their counterparts without building: - where new tags already existed, I removed the old ones - removed descriptive names from chapels and fixed some other minor issues
Closed by Friendly_Ghost
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18004 en) |
---|---|
source | Mapbox Satellite |
Discussion
-
Comment from G1asshouse
The wiki for building:roof:shape very explicitly asks you not to do what you've done here (and with other tags).
Here is a link to the page:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:building:roof:shape?uselang=enHere is the warning:
"Under no circumstances should you (semi-)automatically change “deprecated” tags to something else in the database on a large scale without conforming to the Automated Edits code of conduct. Any such change will be reverted." -
Comment from Lee Carré
What G1asshouse said, plus (once again) smaller changeset areas, please(!)
-
Comment from Friendly_Ghost
> "You are still free to continue to use or interpret this tag as you see fit"
I interpret this tag as a tagging mistake or deprecated variant of roof:shape=* and I use it to find roof shapes for buildings and building parts.
How (else) would you interpret it?
-
Comment from G1asshouse
“How (else) would you interpret it?”
I know that you are quite aware, the warning specifically and clearly puts a limit on what actions mappers can take. “interpret” color as “deprecated” all day long but “Under no circumstances should you (semi-)automatically change “deprecated” tags…”
You’re a very disingenuous person. You do not interact with the community in good faith. You constantly ask questions that you have no interest in the answers to. You dismiss people’s concerns like a horse swats flies. You and the few that are like you destroy the very foundation of this project. It may sound like hyperbole yet a group project, like OSM, requires that members of the group value and respect the opinions and concerns of the other project members. This whole thing is very disheartening. -
Comment from Friendly_Ghost
Dear G1asshouse,
Your personal accusations mean nothing to me.
Best regards
Casper
-
Comment from Lee Carré
“Your personal accusations mean nothing to me.”
He tried to reason with you (in multiple changeset discussions), but you didn't like that either.
Thus, not only must I concur with his conclusions of you, but also point out that you confirm them by demonstrating the problem he describes in your dismissal of his observations.Like I said (in the lengthy, ~26 comment discussion); can't reason with unreasonable people.
Perhaps you're a troll, methinks.
Otherwise, why are you here?
I wonder if you'll respond with anything other than fallacies.
-
Comment from Friendly_Ghost
Dear Lee Carré,
Your personal accusations don't mean anything to me either. That long message you sent me earlier was a lot more constructive, though, so I don't mind replying to that properly when I have the time.
Best regards
Casper
-
Comment from user_5359
Hello! Please have a look on https://www.osm.org/way/129771358/history. What is the correct roof:shape?
-
Comment from Friendly_Ghost
Hello! Thank you for reviewing.
Judging from BDOrtho IGN imagery, it looks like a half-hipped roof. That may explain why Porphyrion couldn't make a good choice between hipped and gabled. I took the liberty to update the tag: https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/125238414See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:roof:shape%3Dhalf-hipped for documentation.
- 967056943, v1
- Tour Montparnasse (16406633), v44
- Tour EDF (19546127), v14
- Église Notre-Dame-du-Pré (24029403), v14
- Église Saint-Martin (37222374), v15
- 40770335, v7
- 41476812, v10
- 42568295, v8
- Château de Grignon (42721300), v7
- Le Grand H (42722988), v6
- Mairie de Chavagne (43976149), v9
- 43976150, v8
- 43976359, v8
- 43976374, v6
- 43976375, v8
- 43976377, v9
- 43980165, v6
- Pizzami's (44158616), v10
- 44158626, v7
- 44159195, v6
Relations (2)
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |