Thanks for the comments, I realized it was a bad practice in OSM and changed the title of it.

Yeah, as I said it is not a mandatory thing to do because editors and renders can understand from the relation.

Awesome, you guys work and you are an example for the rest of the community to be more active.

Hi Iyan(almost similar name), yeah, I totally forgot about kabupaten kepulauan Seribu. I added them now, and fixed them a bit, for example each pulau was linked to kabupaten Jakarta Selatan. I also added Pulau Harapan as kelurahan so in total are 6.

I fixed a bit Wikipedia ID when I saw some inconsistency about the links or names. I removed TMII as admin_level=8 relation, and fixed the Sukapura duplication.

Check the 0.2 version and if everything is ok, I will upload it in the next days… https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/1599184/others/osm/boundaries_jakarta_v0.2.osm.zip

Great work in HOT Indonesia btw.

Best Regards.

Here is the second part: https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/capiscuas/diary/37430

I did a new post explaining the cleaning scripts. http://www.openstreetmap.org/user/capiscuas/diary/36340

Hello walter, yeah, that’s on my plan, I am quite aware of how to create “good” boundary relations without overlapping ways, I have quite sharp python skills and I’ve xml parsing of osm nodes, ways and relations. That’s why I mentioned ‘automagically’ script in the post.

I recognize that will be the difficult part but that’s the interesting part, everybody does hate doing repetitive tasks :-)

Before deleting anything it needs to be made sure that those routes are really outdated, 3 years is not too long in terms of bus routes to change in my opinion.